Writing  · 

GTA 6 Is Out and I hate playing it.

Games used to be simple enough that almost anyone could find a way to play. Now they’re built around one kind of body. As someone with cerebral palsy, I want to know who decided that was progress.

GTA 6 key art on the left; an original NES controller standing upright on white on the right.
GTA 6 artwork: Rockstar Games. NES controller photo: Evan-Amos, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Grand Theft Auto 6 came out this week. You’ve heard. Everyone’s heard. It was reportedly the most pre-ordered game in history, and it was sitting at around $1 billion in sales a week before it even launched. Broadband providers were sending apology emails because the downloads were choking their networks. Biggest game ever. The cultural event of the year.

I tried to play it. I didn’t get to play the game Rockstar made.

I sat down wanting to love it. From the first minute I was fighting the controller instead of playing. Every chase, every drive, every shootout came with a second challenge stacked on top: getting my hands to do what the buttons demanded. Rockstar designed the missions. Nobody designed that part. It kept pulling me out of the game until it stopped being fun. I’m tired of fighting my own controller.

I have cerebral palsy. So do roughly 17 million people around the world. It’s the most common cause of lifelong physical disability that starts in childhood. For me, it means my hands don’t do what a modern game controller expects them to do.

I’ve been meaning to write this for ten years. I kept putting it off. Not anymore. This week of all weeks, with everyone talking about GTA 6, somebody should talk about this, because most of the GTA coverage won’t.

I used to play games. Loads of them.

Here’s the bit that makes me angriest. I wasn’t always shut out.

When I was a kid, I played the NES constantly. I’d turn the controller on its side, vertically, so the d-pad and the A and B buttons were all lined up under one hand. One hand. That’s all it took. Nobody told me to do that. Nobody designed it for me. I just picked it up and found my own way.

Those games were brutally hard, mind you. But the difficulty was in the timing and the patience, not in whether my hands could physically reach the controls.

The NES pad had eight inputs. Four directions, two buttons, Start and Select. That’s it.

Now pick up a PlayStation DualSense and count. Four on the d-pad. Four face buttons. Four shoulder buttons and triggers. Two sticks, and both of those sticks also click in as buttons. A touchpad. Create. Options. That’s nineteen, before you even get to the PS button or the mute button.

A white PlayStation 5 DualSense controller, with two thumbsticks, a d-pad, four face buttons, a touchpad and shoulder triggers.
Photo: Alex Cochrane, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Nineteen. And every one of them is placed on the assumption that you’ve got two hands, ten working fingers, and you’re holding it exactly the way the designers pictured.

I played games way more when the controls were simple. That isn’t nostalgia. That’s access. When games got more buttons, I got fewer games.

Ergonomics was supposed to be about people like me

The word “ergonomics” gets slapped on everything now. Ergonomic chair. Ergonomic mouse. Ergonomic controller. So let’s go back to what it actually meant.

A British psychologist called Hywel Murrell gave the modern field its name at a meeting at the Admiralty in 1949. (The word itself goes back further, to the Polish scientist Wojciech Jastrzębowski in 1857.) The whole idea of the field was simple and decent: fit work to people, not force people to fit work. In the 1950s there was literally a European project called “fitting the task to the worker”.

Fit the task to the worker. Fit the controller to the player.

Somewhere along the way, that got flipped on its head. “Ergonomic” stopped meaning fits people and started meaning fits one specific kind of person really, really well. The modern controller is sculpted. Grips moulded for two palms. Triggers shaped for two index fingers. Sticks set exactly where two thumbs rest. It’s beautiful if you’re the body it was built around.

If you’re not, it’s so f**king hard.

The NES controller was a flat rectangle. By today’s standards it’s the least ergonomic thing imaginable. And that’s exactly why I could use it. It didn’t have an opinion about my hands. It didn’t assume a grip. It left room for me to work it out.

The more perfectly a thing is shaped for one body, the more bodies it shuts out. That’s the bit nobody in the industry seems to want to say out loud.

And here’s the kicker. The NES only had two buttons for one reason. Its designer, Masayuki Uemura, was asked about it years later. His answer: “The most important aspect was cost.” Not accessibility. Money. And still, by accident, it was more inclusive than the controllers we have now.

Metropolis, 1927. Still happening.

There’s a scene in Fritz Lang’s Metropolis that I think about a lot.

In the machine hall, rows of workers stand at a giant machine, shift after shift, heaving its levers back and forth in perfect time. Push, pull, push, pull, until they’re completely spent. The machine dictates every movement. The men just have to keep up.

Black and white still from Metropolis (1927): a towering, steaming machine with rows of tiny workers at its levers, and a crowd gathered below.
Metropolis (1927), directed by Fritz Lang

That’s the image. Human beings bending their bodies to suit a machine, because the machine was never built to suit them.

That’s me with a DualSense in my hands.

Every new generation of controller is sold as more comfortable, more natural, more ergonomic. But for disabled players, it’s the same deal as those workers. The machine sets the terms. We contort ourselves to meet them, or we don’t get to play.

The NES was the opposite. It was dumb enough that I could bend it to suit me.

Why are there so many buttons?

Honest question. Why does it take nearly twenty inputs to play a game?

I don’t think it’s because games need them. I think it’s because the buttons are there, so they get used. Uemura himself said that once Nintendo moved on to the Super Nintendo, it was because developers felt two buttons weren’t enough for creating all kinds of games. Developers. Not players. And it’s been more and more ever since.

Think about what a game actually knows. It knows I’m standing next to a car. It knows I’m next to a door. It knows there’s a person in front of me I can talk to. It knows I’m on a bike, or in the water, or aiming at something. So why do I need a different button for each of those? Why can’t one button mean “do the obvious thing here”?

Games should know context. Shouldn’t the game know what I want to do?

And make it a choice. Racing games have done this for decades: automatic gearbox or manual. Nobody thinks automatic is cheating, and nobody who loves the clutch is forced to give it up. Context-sensitive controls should work the same way. An option, sitting right next to the full layout, for whoever needs it.

Does anyone, disabled or not, actually enjoy memorising what twenty different button combinations do in twenty different situations? I doubt it. You just get used to it. I can’t get used to it, because my hands won’t let me.

I genuinely don’t understand why you’d ever need more than four buttons to do anything. Start from four. Make the game smart. Then let people add more if they want them. Simpler doesn’t mean dumber. It means more people get to play.

And then there’s GTA 6

Let me be fair to Rockstar first...

GTA 6 has a bunch of accessibility settings. You can switch a lot of button holds to toggles, there are assists for tapping and holding, there’s a hold delay to stop accidental presses, there’s an auto-drive option, and you can turn down how much damage you take. Some of that will help people. Good.

But here’s what it doesn’t have. There’s no free button remapping.

The biggest game ever made, with the biggest budget the industry has ever seen, and I can’t get to the actions where I can reach them.

I design products for a living. If my team shipped something that left this many people out on day one, we wouldn’t call it finished. We wouldn’t ship it.

The Game Accessibility Guidelines list “allow controls to be remapped / reconfigured” as a basic motor accessibility feature. Basic. As in: easy to do, helps loads of people, should be in pretty much every game.

And it’s not like it can’t be done. Six years ago, The Last of Us Part II let you remap every single command to any input. It came with Right Hand Only and Left Hand Only control schemes built in. It even had a setting where you tell the game how you’re holding the controller, sideways, upside down, whatever, and it rotates the controls to match.

A game in 2020 had a setting for exactly what I did with my NES as a kid. So don’t tell me it’s impossible. It’s a choice.

So why not? Why not let the player assign every action to whatever button they want? What is the downside? Who is harmed by me putting “get in car” where my thumb can actually reach it?

I know remapping isn’t free. Every action has to be tested on every button, the on-screen prompts have to follow, the menus have to cope. I get it. But you’re charging €80 for this game. You can afford it.

“Use the console’s remapping settings,” people say. Sure. PlayStation and Xbox let you swap buttons at system level. But that just swaps physical buttons around, so the on-screen prompts are now wrong, and it doesn’t reduce the number of things I have to do. It’s still twenty actions. They’re just in different places now.

Hold-to-toggle isn’t the same game

I want to say something about the accessibility options games do have, because I think the industry pats itself on the back about these a bit too much.

Turning a long press into a tap, or a button combo into a single press, is useful. I’m not knocking it. But a lot of the time it doesn’t really fix the problem. It changes the experience. I end up playing a slightly different, slightly diluted version of the game, while everyone else plays the real one.

I don’t want a different game. I want the same game, built from the start so that I can play it.

There’s a difference between making an accessible version of something and making something accessible. The first is a side door. The second is just a door.

The Access controller is clever. It’s also a workaround.

Sony deserves credit for the PlayStation Access controller. It was the first time PlayStation ever built a controller with disabled players in mind. It’s a kit with a joystick and 22 swappable parts you can arrange however your body needs. Microsoft’s Xbox Adaptive Controller did similar work before it.

A PlayStation Access controller from above: a round pad ringed with large white buttons and a joystick, on a grey textured mat with cables and extra switches plugged in.
Photo: InclusiveGameLab, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

When Sony’s project lead talked about why they made it, he described meeting someone with cerebral palsy who had to work the right thumbstick with their cheek.

I know that one. In some games I use my mouth, my chin, even my nose to get the job done.

That should have been the moment someone asked: why does this game need a right stick at all, for this person, in this moment? Instead, the answer was a better way to reach the right stick.

And look at the maths. The Access controller has half the buttons of a normal controller and one stick, so for complicated games you need to buy a second one. So now I need two special controllers to manage twenty actions. That’s not a solution to too many buttons. That’s a more expensive way of managing too many buttons.

It’s one of those workers getting a slightly longer lever. He’s still stuck at the machine.

The Access controller is a brilliant answer to the wrong question. The question shouldn’t be “how do we help disabled people press twenty buttons?” It should be “why are there twenty buttons?”

We are not a niche

Before anyone says this is about a tiny group of people:

If GTA 6 sells to even a fraction of those people, that’s millions of players fighting the controller. Or millions who’ve already given up.

What I actually want

It’s not complicated.

  • Full remapping, in every game, as standard. Every action, any button. No excuses, especially from a studio this rich.
  • One-handed schemes built in. Left hand only. Right hand only. Like Naughty Dog did in 2020.
  • Let me tell the game how I hold the controller. Sideways, upside down, whatever works for me.
  • Context-sensitive controls, as an option. One button that does the obvious thing. The game knows where I am. Let it think.
  • Design for four buttons first. Then add complexity for people who want it, instead of starting at twenty and making us claw our way back down.
  • Stop treating accessibility as an add-on. Build it in from the first day of design, not as a menu of patches at the end.

I’m tired

I’m not writing this calmly. I’m mad. I’m tired. I’m sick of it.

I’m sick of watching the whole world talk about a game I can’t properly play. I’m sick of being told the controllers are more comfortable than ever. I’m sick of accessibility being something you bolt on at the end, or buy separately, instead of something you build in from the start.

When I was a kid I played for hours on a flat little grey and black rectangle turned on its side. Nobody designed it for me, and it worked anyway, because it left room for me.

The game should fit the player. That's what ergonomics was supposed to mean.

If you work in games, put full remapping in your next build, argue why you need to use all the buttons the controller has? Can you do it with less buttons? Can you do it with two buttons? Can you factor in context for actions?

If you don’t work in games, send this to someone who does.

References

If you found this interesting, I made a whole podcast series on the history of disability and access.

Cover art for Disability: A Parallel History, a Yarn miniseries: two stone figures, one in chains, reclining on a broken pediment.
Yarn podcast · Season 4

Disability: A Parallel History

A three-part miniseries on the history of disability, told in parallel with the history of everyone else.

Listen on yarnpodcast.com

Get in touch

Currently at Kitman Labs in Dublin. Always happy to talk design.

mrjohnroche (at) gmail.com